Insomnia | Dormer confronts Finch

Why didn't you come forward with this information when she died?

She swore me to secrecy, she didn't want anybody to know about that --

Even when she was dead she didn't want anybody to know? Beaten to death.

I was honoring her wishes --

Her body dumped on a pile of garbage.

I was her friend!

You weren't her friend.

All right, acquaintance, all right? We were close, and I was just –

You were close?

Mm-hmm.

She was... attractive. Did you have sex with her?

She was seventeen!

Seventeen? She was attractive.

I suppose.

Suppose? She was.

Right.

Yeah, so did you have sex with her?

No, I was her mentor.

You bought her things.

Yeah.

Gifts.

Yes.

What kind of gifts?

Books mostly, that's what she loved.

Books?

Mm-hmm.

What about this? [shows him a necklace] You gave her this?

Yes.

Why?

“Why”?

You wanted to see how she looked with it on?

No.

No? Why would you give her jewelry?

Just a present.

Present.

Yeah.

You bought a lot of presents. You bought her a dress.

Yes, what's wrong with that?

No, nothing wrong. I'm just trying to figure out what kind of mentor you were.

I gave her things she couldn't have.

Pff, you just wanted to fuck her, didn't you? You sick son of a bitch!